/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/51464707/615937342.0.jpg)
For 3 years, Miami QB Brad Kaaya has been the face of the Hurricanes’ program. He’s the franchise, the unquestioned starting quarterback, and one of the best to ever play for the Canes.
As he’s progressed into his junior year, Kaaya’s abilities have been dissected by many. Starting from this past summer, Kaaya was listed as a top NFL Draft prospect by many. Through the start of the season, however, Kaaya’s play has led to several people tempering their once-high expectations of him.
Today, Bleacher Report NFL analyst Ian Wharton had a sort of twitter essay about Kaaya. Here goes:
First, a sack that was Kaaya’s fault in Wharton’s opinion.
Second sack of Kaaya was on him. Trips left on 3rd&7, locks on short side WR, when advantage should’ve been opposite slot. pic.twitter.com/lSl2s2YLCY
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
Next, a really good play from Kaaya.....except for that decision on where to throw (you know which play this is)
Everything from Kaaya looked really good here as far as footwork and maneuvering the pocket. But the decision.. pic.twitter.com/7xMCHPEjxe
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
Then, an NFL throw from Kaaya
This was a big-time throw from Kaaya right before halftime. He does have good touch on passes. pic.twitter.com/sBO6D9cMYN
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
No gif here, but another solid play from Kaaya discussed
Touchdown pass before half was nice as well. CB Reynolds and the SAF had a miscommunication, but throw was spot-on regardless.
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
And the video of the above-discussed play
Brad Kaaya to Braxton Berrios. Touchdown. pic.twitter.com/D0rlMtsZuX
— Peter Ariz (@PeterAriz) October 21, 2016
What’s Kaaya’s NFL projection, in Wharton’s opinion? A question:
@NFLFilmStudy despite the poor play this year, do you still think he can be a high-caliber QB?
— Paul (@papapauliee) October 22, 2016
And an answer:
May depend on how we define high-caliber. I think he may be similar to Wentz where a specific situation will allow him to shine quickly. https://t.co/SScm0NO7AW
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
And some of that projection will require a similar improvement like what Wentz did, though Wentz was more natural as a scrambler. https://t.co/SScm0NO7AW
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
Another NFL throw by Brad Kaaya
Third throw from Kaaya that will clearly translate to the NFL. pic.twitter.com/lP0fSYFJfC
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
A take on the spectrum of Kaaya’s performance vs VT
The VT game is the best to get the best spectrum of Kaaya. Sacked 8 times, but I attributed 7 to him. But also had a number of good throws.
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
I respect Wharton and his work, but I FULLY disagree with attributing 7 of the 8 sacks vs VT to Kaaya. But hey, everybody doesn’t have to agree with everything, yanno?
Overall thoughts?
I don’t view Kaaya as an overly “good” prospect, but there are positives in the short game and his touch can make him average in the NFL IMO
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
@NFLFilmStudy pro comparison?
— CJ Bullion (@CJB344) October 22, 2016
For Kaaya..eh..not a clean one. Maybe current Andy Dalton (the one without Hue). Needs a really good surrounding cast and system. https://t.co/dLE0R20HSp
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
Finally, the big question: Does Wharton think Kaaya should stay in college for a 4th year or is he ready to go to the NFL now?
And like I’ve said before, I’d like for Kaaya to go back to Miami for one more season. Plenty of room for improvement still.
— Ian Wharton (@NFLFilmStudy) October 22, 2016
That’s one man’s opinion of the situation. What’s yours? Hop in the comments below and keep the conversation going.